Briefing
Sustainability Series: Part 1 – Road Freight Transport
As the world is facing a global climate crisis pressure is building on industries to do what they can to reduce emissions1. Today, the transport sector accounts for around 21% of global greenhouse gas emissions, 64% of all global oil consumption, 27% of all energy use and 23% of the world’s energy related carbon dioxide emissions2.
The transport sector is therefore, undeniably, in desperate need of finding climate solutions in the face of mounting consumer pressure, competition and increasingly burdensome regulations.
In this sustainability series we will be exploring the climate solutions that could help the transport sector reach net-zero. Within the road, shipping, rail and air freight sectors, we will review the economic and commercial incentives, barriers to change, benefits of and potential issues with such solutions.
Why should the sector change?
In the build up to the latest UN Climate Change Conference (COP 26), governments and industry leaders were urged to do more to build consensus on, and accelerate the transition to, zero emission vehicles (ZEVs). In a positive move towards the transition, over 100 countries, states, cities and organisations signed the Glasgow Declaration on Zero-Emission Cars and Vans to end the sale of internal combustion engines worldwide by 2040. The UK government also announced that all HGVs will be zero-emission by 2040.
Despite recent statistics that the sale of ZEVs is dramatically increasing (ZEVs are forecast to be 70% of all new UK car sales in 2040 3), and the UK is well on its way to achieving this target, commercial challenges remain for road freight and logistics businesses whose profitability depends on transition investment vs. value realisation concerns.
Legal/Regulatory Incentives
The regulation 4 setting CO2 emission standards for heavy-duty vehicles entered into force on 14 August 2019 and set targets to reduce the average CO2 emissions from new HGVs by 15% in 2025 and by 30% in 20305. The expected benefits include saving around 54 million tonnes of CO2 in the period 2020 to 2030 and up to 170 million tonnes of oil over the period 2020 to 20406.
Vehicle and fuel taxation has been designed to incentivise commercial operators to purchase and operate more sustainable HGVs 7. Whilst the world’s first ultra-low emission zone was launched in London in 2019, more local authorities across the UK are also introducing clear air zones (CAZ). The need to avoid consequent charges and potential fines will undoubtedly encourage freight operators to update their fleets.
The need for more sustainable HGVs will further drive zero and low emission vehicle demand thereby significantly reducing the traditional HGV diesel market and eventually displacing their competitiveness in the market. Commercial operators will therefore have little choice but to transition to more sustainable practices despite the financial impact of doing so.
Market/Consumer Incentives
Operators will also need to adjust their internal procedures and governance to align with external pressures and incentives. As such, they will be looking to work with customers and suppliers who will support them in reaching their targets and assist them to track performance.
Companies will need to be transparent and collaborative. With shared incentives and an appreciation of differing emission profiles, companies can work together towards a more sustainable future.
Entities that act inconsistently with commitments and targets, or that mislead customers about their products and actions, will face increased criticism and in the longer term, possible legal action 8. As the industry changes, those who don’t transition to more sustainable practices will inevitably feel the repercussions of failing to adapt.
Separately, litigation risks can arise from a company’s climate change action (or non-action) and any failure to manage the physical and economic risks. Such risks are evident by the rise in climate change litigation in recent years.
Solutions/Alternative Options
Emerging technologies and alternative fuels play a substantial role in reducing emissions in the road freight sector. For many, upgrading an entire existing fleet will not be a viable option and instead, existing vehicles will need to be retrofitted for the use of alternative fuels. However, with a plethora of different fuel options available, continuing trials and opposing recommendations, the choice is not straightforward. The table below summarises the advantages and disadvantages of a selection of popular alternatives against the current use of diesel.
Table 1 – Fuel Comparison
| Advantages | Disadvantages | |
|---|---|---|
| Diesel |
|
|
| Electric |
|
|
| Hydrogen |
|
|
| Biodiesel* |
|
|
| Natural Gas |
|
|
* Firoz, S. (2017) A review: Advantages and Disadvantages of Biodiesel. Available here
The government’s latest Freight Carbon Review focusses on liquefied and compressed natural gas, biomethane and liquid biofuels as these are the fuels that are considered suitable for use in the current generation of HGV engines. Whilst these fuels offer significant potential to decarbonise the sector, they are currently only sustainable for the short to medium term as the production and use of some still lead to substantial greenhouse gas emissions.
A longer-term solution is the use and investment in electric highways (e-highways), where 700-volt power lines are hung from poles along the inside lane of the motorway, from which lorries connect via a pantograph which provides power to the motor. E-highways ensure no energy is lost between the power lines and the lorries. However, e-highways require a whole new set of infrastructure on the roads and an entire fleet of compatible vehicles 9. Studies estimate that the cost of building power lines to cover 65% of the UK’s lorry routes will be in the region of £20 billion10. Yet trials have also demonstrated that e-highway technology could be deployed reasonably quickly around the UK’s road network, within the next 15-20 years or potentially sooner11. E-highways could therefore be one of the longer-term solutions the industry is searching for.
Conclusion
Whilst significant progress has been made, sustainable road freight still requires substantial infrastructure investment. The commercial reality is that currently, many operators can’t afford to upgrade entire fleets or make the switch to alternative fuels without further support from the government. The transition path is also not clear and guidance is required to clarify where investment should be focussed. However, one aspect is certainly clear – the transport landscape is changing, and road freight and logistics businesses will need to adapt to survive.
How HFW can help
HFW has a wealth of experience in the transport and logistics sector and can work with clients to achieve their sustainability goals by providing solutions for both sustainable transport and logistics and the entire life cycle of the sustainable transportation system.
Footnotes
- Ritchie H. (2020) Cars, planes, trains: where do CO2 emissions from transport come from? Our World in Data. Available at: Cars, planes, trains: where do CO2 emissions from transport come from? - Our World in Data
- Mead L. (2021) The Road to Sustainable Transport - Still Only One Earth: Lessons from 50 years of UN sustainable development policy. Available at: https://www.iisd.org/articles/road-sustainable-transport
- Research from Bloomberg New Energy Finance, commissioned by the UK COP Presidency.
- Regulation (EU) 2019/1242.
- European Commission, Climate Action. Reducing CO2 emissions from heavy-duty vehicles. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/clima/eu-action/transport-emissions/road-transport-reducing-co2-emissions-vehicles/reducing-co2-emissions-heavy-duty-vehicles_en
- European Commission, Climate Action. Reducing CO2 emissions from heavy-duty vehicles. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/clima/eu-action/transport-emissions/road-transport-reducing-co2-emissions-vehicles/reducing-co2-emissions-heavy-duty-vehicles_en
- Committee on Climate Change. (2019) Net Zero Technical Report. Available at: https://www.theccc.org.uk/publication/net-zero-technical-report/
- Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment (2021) Global trends in climate change litigation: 2021 snapshot. Available at: https://www.lse.ac.uk/granthaminstitute/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Global-trends-in-climate-change-litigation_2021-snapshot.pdf
- Stacy, T (2021). E-highways: why motorway cables are probably not the best way to decarbonise lorries. Available at: E-highways: why motorway cables are probably not the best way to decarbonise lorries (theconversation.com)
- Ainalis, D.T., Thorne, C., and Cebon D. (2020) Decarbonising the UK’s Long-Haul Road Freight at Minimum Economic Cost. Available at: SRF-WP-UKEMS-v2 (csrf.ac.uk)
- Cebon, D. (2020) Long-haul lorries powered by hydrogen or electricity? Available at: Long-Haul Lorries Powered by Hydrogen or Electricity? - The Centre For Sustainable Road Freight (csrf.ac.uk)
We are committed to using our legal and sector expertise, networks and corporate responsibility initiatives to enable sustainable practices across all of our operations and the industries that we service, and to drive meaningful and lasting change.
Click here to visit our dedicated sustainability hub.
