Skip to content
Briefing

Beyond the contract: Implied terms in construction disputes

This article is the third in HFW’s Global Construction Team’s series on extra-contractual remedies in construction disputes across England and Wales, Saudi Arabia (KSA), Kuwait, the UAE, Hong Kong and Australia. In this article, we explore a range of implied obligations which can be imposed on parties by operation of law, regardless of (and in some cases irrespective of) what the contract says.

Introduction

Construction contracts are typically drafted with great care to reflect the agreed allocation of risk between the parties. Standard form contracts such as FIDIC or NEC usually address these issues, which is why they are routinely used on major construction projects. Behind the express terms of any contract, however, sits a second layer of obligations implied into the contract by its governing law. These obligations apply whether or not the parties have negotiated them and, sometimes, regardless of whether they would have agreed them if asked. Some obligations may even be implied contrary to what the parties would have agreed.

These obligations take many forms. Some are imposed by statute or civil codes: obligations as to the quality of goods and materials, fitness for purpose, and to exercise reasonable skill and care. Others originate in common law: duties to co-operate in performance, not to hinder the other party’s ability to perform, and to exercise contractual discretions rationally. In some legal systems, a general duty of good faith is implied across the whole of the contractual relationship. In others, it is not recognised at all.

This article examines the terms and obligations implied into construction contracts under common law jurisdictions – specifically those in England and Wales, Hong Kong and Australia – and compares them with the position in civil law jurisdictions across the Middle East.

We test these doctrines against a case study drawn from a FIDIC Yellow Book 1999 project, unfolding across two stages: a disputed extension of time and a defects claim.

The common law and civil law divide

In common law jurisdictions, the law first asks: what did the parties agree? Implied terms are generally subordinate to the parties’ express bargain. They exist to fill gaps, make the contract workable, and give effect to the parties’ presumed intentions. They do not ordinarily override or contradict express terms. The principal exceptions are mandatory statutory terms and, occasionally, terms implied by law into particular categories of relationship.

In civil law jurisdictions, the position is different. While the civil codes similarly do not generally displace the parties’ express agreement, they do supplement it through obligations arising from law, custom, good faith and the nature of the transaction. Express rights and obligations are assessed against a broader framework of mandatory legal principles such as good faith. Good faith is not an exception, but a core principle that affects the interpretation, negotiation and performance of the contract throughout the contractual relationship. The key distinction, therefore, is that the civil law analysis goes beyond the express wording of the contract. The common law system, on the other hand, attempts to keep within the four corners of the contract.

The practical consequences of this difference are profound. These differences are illustrated in the case studies later in this article, where the same Engineer’s determination of an extension of time claim and the same defects claim brought after termination produce different outcomes depending on the governing law.

The legal landscape – common law

Terms implied by statute

Most legal systems place great store by the freedom to contract. Yet this freedom is in tension with the application of mandatory or minimum statutory terms.

Take a design-and-build project under English or Hong Kong law. The relevant statutory regimes in both jurisdictions imply key obligations into such contracts:

Implied statutory termsEngland & WalesHong Kong
Basis for implicationArises as a matter of law under the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 (SGSA)Arises as a matter of law under the Supply of Services (Implied Terms) Ordinance (Cap. 457) and the Sale of Goods Ordinance (Cap. 26)
Quality of goods / materialsGoods and materials incorporated into the works must be of satisfactory quality (s. 4 SGSA).An equivalent obligation of merchantable quality.
Fitness for purposeWhere the customer makes known a particular purpose, the goods must be reasonably fit for that purpose (ss. 4(4) and (5) SGSA).An equivalent obligation of fitness for purpose.
Reasonable skill and careThe service element of the contract – including design and construction – must be performed with reasonable skill and care (s. 13 SGSA).An equivalent obligation of reasonable skill and care.
ScopeContracts for works and services between businesses.Contracts for the supply of goods and services.
Exclusions / modificationsCan be modified or excluded by sufficiently clear wording, subject to statutory control.Exclusion is possible, subject to the Control of Exemption Clauses Ordinance (Cap. 71).

The Australian position differs in route but arrives at a broadly similar destination. Australia’s statutory equivalents to the SGSA are generally directed towards consumer or domestic building contracts and not commercial construction contracts. However, equivalent terms (as to quality, fitness for purpose, and due care and skill) may be implied in fact under the common law where necessary to give business efficacy to the contract. The only exception is if they are excluded by clear language or inconsistent with any express term.

Terms implied by common law

Common law legal systems also imply obligations from the nature of the contract itself. However, the implication of good faith is not as wide as under the civil law regimes addressed below.

As a rule, common law systems do not recognise a general duty of “good faith” in contract. English, Australian and Hong Kong law’s refusal to recognise such a general duty is based on the principle that sophisticated parties are deemed capable of looking after their own interests. Courts will instead develop “piecemeal solutions in response to demonstrated problems of unfairness.” 1

The key obligations are these.

Express good faith obligations

Where parties expressly agree an obligation of good faith, it will be enforced. Its content depends on the contractual context but, at its core, it requires honesty and prohibits “commercially unacceptable” and unreasonable conduct.2

Duty to co-operate and the obligation to give timely possession of the site

An implied duty of co-operation exists wherever performance requires the active participation of both parties. Under English law, where an employer is under a contractual obligation to give the contractor possession of the site, the law implies an obligation to do so within a reasonable time if no precise date has been specified. Australian law extends this to an implied obligation not to interrupt or withdraw possession once given.3 Hong Kong law recognises an equivalent implied obligation on employers not to hinder or prevent the contractor’s performance.

In our experience, delayed possession is one of the most common forms of employer-caused delay in construction projects. The implied obligation that possession will be given within a reasonable time (or, where a date is specified, by that date) is therefore one of the most practically significant implied terms in any construction contract.

The duty of co-operation is also closely linked to the prevention principle, which prohibits one party from relying on the other’s failure to perform an obligation that the first party’s own conduct made impossible.4

Braganza duty

An implied duty of rationality exists wherever a contract gives one party a discretion whose exercise affects the rights of both. Known as the Braganza duty after the UK Supreme Court’s decision in Braganza v BP Shipping Ltd [2015] UKSC 17, this requires the decision-maker to act honestly and in good faith, to ask the right question, to take account of all obviously relevant matters, to exclude irrelevant ones, and to reach a conclusion that is not so outrageous that no rational decision-maker could have reached it. Australian law has parallel doctrines achieving a broadly similar outcome. Hong Kong law also recognises similar doctrines.

We return to this doctrine in the case study further below, where it is tested against the Engineer’s nil determination on the contractor’s extension of time claim.

Relational contracts and good faith as a matter of fact

In contracts that are genuinely long-term and collaborative (e.g., joint ventures, framework agreements, alliancing arrangements, PFI or PPP arrangements), English and Australian courts may, in appropriate cases, imply a broader duty of good faith as a matter of fact. Such “relational” contracts will not, however, automatically give rise to duties of good faith as a matter of law: the touchstone remains whether the implied duty is necessary (not whether the contract is relational).5 In Australia, jurisprudence on this point is not uniform across states, with the High Court yet to resolve the uncertainty.

Under English and Hong Kong law, contractual rights and obligations are generally determined by the parties’ express bargain, subject only to a limited range of implied duties where necessary to give business efficacy to the agreement. Under UAE, KSA and Kuwaiti law, however, the analysis does not stop with the written words of the contract. Courts and tribunals will also consider the requirements of good faith, custom, usage and the nature of the transaction. Those principles may supplement the parties’ express obligations, require a degree of co-operation in performance and, in appropriate cases, restrict the exercise of contractual rights where doing so would constitute an abuse of rights or otherwise contravene the requirements of good faith.

The legal landscape – civil law

The Middle East: UAE, KSA and Kuwait

In civil law jurisdictions, obligations concerning service quality, proper performance, co-operation and good faith arise primarily from the civil codes. In the Middle East, civil codes reflect a combination of the Napoleonic Code, civil law principles and Islamic jurisprudence. Accordingly, obligations are implied by law into contractual relationships as part of the broader legal framework governing contracts.

Quality, Workmanship and Professional Conduct

All three jurisdictions impose mandatory obligations of quality and professional conduct on contractors. Under Article 818 of the UAE Civil Code,6 contractors must execute works in accordance with the contract specifications and, where specifications are silent, in accordance with good practice and the rules of the profession. Similar provisions exist under the KSA Civil Transactions Law (KSA CTL) (Art. 465) and the Kuwait Civil Code (Art. 666).

Decennial Liability

In the introductory article in this series, we highlighted the privity problem: where a building is sold on to a subsequent purchaser and structural defects emerge years later, the purchaser’s ability to recover is very limited in the absence of a direct warranty or a statutory duty of care. Common law jurisdictions address this through collateral warranties, statutory routes and third-party rights legislation.

The Middle East civil codes take a different approach. They impose decennial liability (a mandatory, ten-year, strict liability obligation) on contractors and design engineers for total or partial collapse of a building or other fixed structure, and for any defect threatening its stability or safety. Under Article 823 of the UAE Civil Code, any term purporting to exempt or limit the contractor’s or engineer’s liability is void. Similar provisions exist in the Kuwait Civil Code (Arts. 692 and 697), and under KSA’s Implementing Regulations of the Saudi Building Code Application Law (Art. 29).

We return to this regime in the second part of the case study further below, where it is tested against a defects claim brought after termination.

Liquidated Damages and Judicial Power to Adjust

In all three Middle East jurisdictions, and unlike the common law jurisdictions, courts retain the express power to adjust agreed liquidated damages provisions.

The UAE Civil Code,7 KSA CTL8 and Kuwait Civil Code9 all permit the court to adjust the agreed compensation and void any agreement to the contrary. The court may reduce the compensation if the debtor proves that the amount was excessive or that part of the original obligation was performed. Under the KSA CTL and the UAE Civil Code, the creditor may claim an amount exceeding the agreed compensation if it proves fraud or gross fault.

This is a significant departure from the English, Hong Kong and Australian positions, under which agreed liquidated damages clauses are generally enforced as written, subject to the rule against penalties. Parties operating in the Middle East should not assume that an agreed liquidated damages rate will be applied without scrutiny.

Duty of Good Faith

Unlike their common law counterparts, the civil law jurisdictions of the UAE, KSA and Kuwait recognise good faith as a fundamental principle of the law of obligations, informing the interpretation, performance and enforcement of contracts.

The UAE Civil Code10 requires parties to perform their contracts in accordance with their terms and consistently with the requirements of good faith. Moreover, the UAE Civil Code expressly extends good faith requirements to the pre-contractual negotiation stage and stipulates that deliberate non-disclosure of a material fact affecting the validity of a contract constitutes bad faith.11 The good faith doctrine is reinforced by the separate prohibition on the abuse of rights, which prevents parties from exercising contractual or legal rights in a manner intended to cause harm or that is disproportionate to any legitimate benefit obtained.12

The KSA CTL also reflects a broad codification of principles that were historically derived from Sharia jurisprudence. Article 95 requires contracts to be performed in accordance with their terms and the requirements of good faith. The provision’s significance lies in a wider legal framework emphasising fairness, transparency, co-operation and the prevention of unjust enrichment and abusive conduct.

Kuwaiti law places particular emphasis on good faith as an aspect of loyalty and fair dealing between contracting parties. The Civil Code provides that contracts extend beyond their express wording and include obligations arising from, amongst other things, the requirements of good faith. This reflects the traditional civil law view that contracts create a relationship requiring co-operation rather than a mere exchange of rights and obligations.

For construction projects, this means that contractual relationships are commonly viewed as cooperative ventures. Rights and remedies are generally interpreted against a background expectation that parties will act honestly and fairly in pursuing their contractual interests. Consequently, contractual rights that appear absolute under the common law may be subject to greater judicial and arbitral scrutiny in the Middle East.

Case study

The practical difference between the common and civil law is significant. The following case study applies the principles discussed above to a FIDIC Yellow Book 1999 construction project, illustrating how the same facts produce different legal conclusions across legal systems.

Case study part 1: The Engineer’s determination

The facts

A Contractor is engaged under a FIDIC Yellow Book 1999 contract where the time for completion is three years. At month 18, employer-caused variations delay the critical path, overlapping with the contractor’s own design and procurement delays. The Contractor claims an 18-month extension of time under Sub-Clause 8.4(e). The Engineer, without consultation, determines a nil award, finding the events fall outside Sub-Clause 8.4(e) and that the contractor’s own delays were concurrent. The Contractor disputes the determination.

QuestionCommon law (England, Australia, Hong Kong)Middle East (UAE, KSA, Kuwait)
Does a good faith/rationality duty constrain the Engineer’s determination?Possibly, under Sub-Clause 3.5, but the point remains open to debate. Even if it applies, it governs only the Engineer’s process, not the contractor’s substantive entitlement, which a tribunal will determine for itself. Hong Kong is more willing to look behind the determination where employer interference compromises the Engineer’s independence (as in Chun Wo Building Construction Limited and Metta Resources Limited (HCCT 29/2013, 19 August 2016)).Yes. The good faith obligation applies to the determination itself. A nil award made without consultation, and without addressing the dominant cause of delay, is open to challenge, reinforced by the prohibition on abuse of rights where a nil award is tactical rather than merits-based.
How is concurrent delay treated?England determines entitlement by reference to the contractual mechanism and established concurrent delay principles. Australian courts have not developed a distinct concurrent delay doctrine; causation remains the touchstone, although New South Wales courts have shown a greater willingness, in the context of certifier and superintendent discretions generally, to imply obligations of good faith or reasonableness into the exercise of such powers.This approach is also consistent with Article 340(3) of the new UAE Civil Code, which permits agreed compensation to be reduced where the creditor’s own fault contributed to the occurrence or increase of the damage. In the context of concurrent delay, the provision may therefore allow the consequences of employer and contractor responsibility to be apportioned when assessing agreed delay compensation, rather than necessarily producing an all-or-nothing result. 

Case study part 2: Defects, workmanship and entire agreement clauses

The facts

Five years after termination (three years after completion by a substitute contractor), structural defects appear in sections built before termination. The Employer claims against the original contractor for remediation costs, relying on: the Sub-Clause 4.1 fitness for purpose warranty; the Sub-Clause 7.1 workmanship obligation; and the SGSA’s statutory terms of reasonable skill and care (s. 13) and satisfactory quality/fitness for purpose (ss. 4-5). The contractor invokes the contract’s entire agreement clause to exclude any liability founded on implied terms, raising the question of whether that clause defeats the claim.

QuestionCommon law (England, Australia, Hong Kong)Middle East (UAE, KSA, Kuwait)
Does fitness for purpose apply regardless of due skill and care?Yes. A fitness for purpose warranty (Sub-Clause 4.1) is a strict obligation: a contractor can be liable for a non-conforming result even having exercised reasonable skill and care (MT Højgaard).13 Same position in Australia and Hong Kong. The SGSA’s skill and care and quality/fitness terms (ss.4-13) add fault-based alternatives.Yes, in substance. Under the civil codes, contractors must execute works in accordance with the contract specifications and, where specifications are silent, in accordance with good practice and the rules of the profession.14
Does the entire agreement clause exclude implied/statutory terms?No, on these facts SGSA terms can only be excluded by clear, inconsistent wording (subject to UCTA’s reasonableness test where it applies); Australian courts likewise generally require an entire agreement clause to address implied terms expressly before it will be read as excluding them, although the strictness of that approach is not entirely uniform. A standard clause that says nothing about implied terms will usually leave liability intact.No. An entire agreement clause is generally directed at prior agreements and representations; it does not exclude obligations imposed by the civil code, particularly mandatory ones.
Does mandatory decennial liability override any contractual limitation?Not applicable under English law, where a carefully drafted limitation clause may, in principle, restrict recovery, subject to statutory controls.Yes. The UAE’s mandatory ten-year decennial liability regime (and analogous Kuwaiti and Saudi regimes) renders void any clause purporting to limit or exclude liability for structural defects; a purported two-year limitation clause would be ineffective here.

Key takeaways

Construction contracts are detailed documents, but the legal system governing them can matter just as much as the words on the page. Here are the practical points to take away.

Governing law determines what your contract actually says

In the Middle East, the civil codes read obligations into every contract the parties have not expressly addressed. Good faith in performance, obligations arising from trade custom, and professional standards are part of the bargain whether or not they appear in the written agreement. Under English law, none of that happens automatically. A contractor or employer operating under a Middle East governing law may therefore have both greater rights and greater exposure than the contract alone would suggest. Governing law is not a boilerplate decision and can have a severe impact on a party’s ‘standard contract’.

Some Middle East liabilities cannot be managed through contract drafting

Decennial liability is the clearest example. In the UAE, the contractor and supervising engineer are jointly and severally liable for ten years from delivery for collapse or structural defects, and any clause limiting or excluding that liability is void. Equivalent regimes apply in Kuwait and KSA. No limitation of liability clause, however carefully drafted, changes this. Clients need to understand that before they agree a contract structure and suitable risk mitigation, not after a defect emerges.

In the Middle East, good faith applies to how rights are exercised, not just whether they exist

Under English law, if a party has a clear contractual right, it can generally exercise it without justifying its reasons. In the Middle East, the abuse of rights doctrine (Art. 106, UAE Civil Code) means that a court or tribunal will also look at whether that right was exercised proportionately and for a legitimate purpose. This applies broadly across contractual rights and remedies. A party whose own conduct contributed to the problem it relies on to exercise a right faces a harder argument in the Middle East than in an English court.

Agreed remedies are subject to greater judicial intervention in the Middle East

Under English law, a liquidated damages clause is generally enforced as agreed, provided it is not a penalty. In the Middle East, courts retain an express power to reduce agreed compensation found to be excessive, regardless of what the contract says (Art. 340, UAE Civil Code; equivalent provisions in KSA and Kuwait). The agreed figure is the starting point, not necessarily the outcome. Clients should factor this in when negotiating LD rates and when assessing the value of an LD clause as a risk management tool.

The new UAE Civil Code introduced obligations that did not previously exist in codified form

The new Civil Code imposes express pre-contractual good faith obligations for the first time. Parties negotiating contracts in the UAE now face potential liability for bad faith conduct during negotiations, including deliberate non-disclosure of material facts (Art. 121, UAE Civil Code). This is new ground and its boundaries have yet to be tested in the courts. Clients should be aware of it and take it into account in how they approach contract negotiations.

An entire agreement clause is not a safe harbour against implied terms

A common assumption is that a standard entire agreement clause shields a contractor from liability under implied terms. It generally does not. Under English, Australian and Hong Kong law, implied terms as to quality, fitness for purpose, and reasonable skill and care survive an entire agreement clause unless the clause expressly and clearly addresses them, and any exclusion remains subject to statutory reasonableness controls where they apply. A clause silent on implied terms leaves the contractor’s liability intact. Clients relying on boilerplate to shed this risk should check the clause actually says what they think it says.

Gabriella Sung, Trainee Solicitor, assisted in the preparation of this briefing.

Footnotes

  1. Interfoto Picture Library Ltd v Stiletto Visual Programmes Ltd [1989] 1 QB 433.
  2. Re Compound Photonics Group Ltd [2022] EWCA Civ 1371.
  3. Carr v JA Berriman Pty Ltd 89 CLR 327 at [336].
  4. We will address the prevention principle in detail later in this series.
  5. Svella Connect Limited v Virgin Media Limited [2026] EWHC 2223 (TCC) at [113].
  6. References in this article to the UAE Civil Code, unless stated otherwise, are to Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025, which came into force on 1 June 2026 and replaced the old UAE Civil Code (Law No. 5 of 1985).
  7. Article 340 of the UAE Civil Code.
  8. Article 179 of the KSA CTL.
  9. Articles 303 and 304 of the Kuwait Civil Code.
  10. Article 221 of the UAE Civil Code.
  11. Article 121 of the UAE Civil Code.
  12. Article 106 of the UAE Civil Code.
  13. MT Højgaard A/S v E.ON Climate & Renewables UK Robin Rigg East Ltd [2017] UKSC 59.
  14. Art. 818, UAE Civil Code; Art. 465, KSA CTL; Art. 666, Kuwait Civil Code.
Published
19 November 2026
Reading Time
23 minutes