Skip to content
Briefing

London Engineering Group launches new model clauses

30 years on from original publication, the London Engineering Group (LEG) has revised its suite of defect exclusion clauses. The LEG/26 clauses, together with an accompanying explanatory commentary, are available from the IUA’s clauses database at iua.co.uk/clauses.

As before, the clauses are intended to provide progressively wider cover:

  • LEG 1/26 operates as an absolute exclusion for damage caused by a defect;
  • LEG 2/26 excludes the cost that would have been incurred to replace or rectify the property having the defect as if such defect had been discovered immediately prior to the damage;
  • LEG 3/26 excludes only the additional cost incurred to improve the original material, workmanship, design, plan or specification.

Despite having been in widespread use for 30 years, there has been no ruling of the English Courts upon the meaning of any of the clauses. However, revision was prompted by Canadian and US Court rulings as to what constitutes damage and what constitutes improvement.

Damage

The contradiction between the approach of the English and US Courts as to what constitutes damage is neatly illustrated by the decision of the English Court of Appeal in Messer UK, Terra Nitrogen UK and Thomas Hardy Packaging v Bacardi- Martini [2002], which concerned the ambit of a limitation of liability clause, and that of a US Court in National Union Fire Insurance v Terra Nitrogen UK [2003] which concerned the subsequent insurance claim. What happened was that carbon dioxide contaminated with benzene was mixed with Bacardi concentrate to create Bacardi Breezers. The English Court held that there had been no damage to the ingredients as the ingredients ceased to exist and no damage to the finished product as it did not exist prior to creation and was simply a defective product. This approach was upheld in an insurance context in MOK Petro Energy v Argo and Others [2024]. However, the US Courts rejected this approach and held that the contaminated CO2 damaged the Bacardi concentrate.

The Canadian and US Courts have followed this US approach in the context of LEG 2 and LEG 3.

Acciona v Allianz [2015] concerned the construction of an eight-storey hospital extension. As a result of improper formwork and shoring/reshoring procedures, the concrete floor slabs over-deflected and cracked. The Canadian Court rejected insurers’ argument that as the floor slabs had never existed in a satisfactory state the over-deflection /cracking did not amount to “damage” and instead held that the LEG 2 exclusion only excluded the cost of implementing proper formwork and shoring/reshoring procedures before it caused the over-deflection/cracking, and on the facts such cost was nil.

South Capitol Bridgebuilders v Lexington [2023] concerned LEG 3, which it described as ” egregiously ambiguous” and “bordering incomprehensible”. During the construction of a bridge, inadequate vibration caused honeycombing and voiding in the concrete. The Court rejected insurers’ arguments that (1) insured property was not altered, merely defectively constructed (2) the concrete components did not become defective because they were defective from the start and (3) the incorporation of defective components into a larger project does not constitute damage. The Court held that the bridge’s reduced weight-bearing capacity amounted to an “alteration” to that bridge.

In Archer Western-De Moya v Ace [2024], which also concerned the construction of a bridge and LEG 3, the cement mix was adulterated with excessive fly ash which was then mixed with water to form concrete batches which were incorporated into various project structures. It was held that the cement mix and fly ash were each in a satisfactory state before being combined whereupon first the cement mix and then the concrete batches were contaminated and damaged and then the concrete batches were incorporated into the project structures causing damage to adjacent components and to the structural integrity.

The new LEG clauses reject the US approach by adding the following wording:

“The existence of a Defect shall not constitute Damage”.

“damage or Damage shall mean: (i) physical loss, or (ii) physical destruction, or (iii) adverse physical change of property existent at the time such loss, destruction or change occurs”.

“The introduction, integration or addition of property which has a Defect to Insured Property shall not constitute Damage “

Access Damage

To reinforce the limited nature of LEG 2 cover, in circumstances where the repair immediately before the damage could be the same as that undertaken after the damage because of access damage to enable repair, wording has been added to exclude such access damage as follows:

LEG 1/26 & LEG 2/26:

“Insurers shall exclude intentional Damage caused to enable the replacement or rectification of Insured Property having a Defect”.

LEG 3/26:

“Insurers shall exclude intentional Damage caused to enable the replacement or rectification of Insured Property having a Defect (“Access Damage”), unless such Access Damage is necessary for the repair, replacement, reinstatement or rectification of Damage”.

The commentary explains that where other non-intentional damage has occurred, accessing defective property may coincide with the repair of this damage in which case the access damage costs may form part of the recoverable loss.

Improvement

The US cases also debated what constitutes the cost incurred to improve the original workmanship and concluded that it is subject to more than one reasonable interpretation: Is it the cost of fixing something? Or the cost of making it better than originally planned eg replacing concrete with gold? Or just the additional cost incurred to improve?

The LEG 3/26 clause now clarifies this issue:

“Insurers shall exclude … the additional cost incurred to improve the material, workmanship, design, plan or specification that was utilised to make, install, build or construct the Insured Property that has the Defect”

Comment

LEG’s aim of providing greater clarity on what constitutes “damage” as distinct from a “defect,” and what the word “improvement” means in the context of LEG 3’s exclusion has largely been achieved but arguably at the expense of narrowing the opportunity for pragmatic adjustment, which has avoided English law litigation for 30 years. Furthermore, it has to be said that the Thomas Hardy v Bacardi Court of Appeal decision on damage/defect has been widely criticised especially when applied in the context of construction insurance (the purpose of which is to insure the stage of “creation”) and could be challenged judicially in the future. The formal reinforcement of the Bacardi position in this context could therefore be controversial, and it does appear to favour insurers. Brokers will need to explain the changes to their clients, and we wait and see what the response of the market will be. In the meantime, existing policies written on LEG /96 or /06 terms remain in force.

Published
16 November 2026
Reading Time
7 minutes