HFW wins precedent-setting derivatives case
Global, sector-focused law firm HFW has successfully defended its client in a precedent-setting derivatives case involving proceedings in Denmark and before the English High Court.
The firm represented global agri-business Olam International Limited in a dispute relating to cash-settled derivatives contracts it had agreed with Danish bunker trading company O.W. Supply & Trading A/S (OW) in 2013.
OW filed for bankruptcy in 2014 and the bankrupt estate subsequently pursued claims against Olam and two shipping companies over outstanding sums owed under the derivatives contracts.
HFW successfully applied to the English High Court, which ordered that Olam was not obliged to make any payment to OW for the open positions, due to it being in bankruptcy.
OW's bankruptcy estate then brought proceedings in Denmark "to have an authoritative Danish decision as to whether the estate is right that mandatory Danish insolvency law takes precedence over contract terms contrary to Danish insolvency law, and the bankruptcy estate has a legal and creditable interest in having this issue settled in Denmark".
The Danish District Court and now the Danish Western High Court on appeal found that they did not have jurisdiction to hear this matter. The Court held that the claim was a bankruptcy claim and not a claim for fulfilment of a contract giving grounds for jurisdiction – and even if it had been, the claim still had a character of a "money claim" and therefore fell outside of the Danish Administration of Justice Act, which OW's bankruptcy estate was relying on to bring proceedings in Denmark.
This decision contrasts with the outcome of a similar case against Danish dry bulk shipping company XO Shipping in 2017. In that case, the Danish Courts found they had jurisdiction and ordered XO to pay sums due under derivatives contracts to a bankrupt estate.
HFW's team comprised partner Brian Perrott and associate Prashant Kukadia. Olam was represented in Danish proceedings by Johannes Grove Nielsen at Danish law firm Bech-Bruun.
The bankrupt estate was represented by Peter Bang at Danish law firm Plesner.
HFW partner Brian Perrott:
"This is a significant decision that sets an interesting precedent: if you are an international company and enter into derivatives contracts with a Danish company that subsequently goes bankrupt, you now can't face claims in Denmark. We am very happy that our tried-and-tested derivatives experience helped our client achieve a good result."
HFW is a leading global law firm in the aerospace, commodities, construction, energy, insurance and shipping sectors. The firm has almost 600 fee-earners, including 180 partners, based in 18 offices across the Americas, Europe, the Middle East, Asia and Australia. We take a progressive approach to our roles in commercial business – thinking creatively and pragmatically to support our clients. HFW prides itself on its deep industry expertise and its entrepreneurial, creative and collaborative culture.
For further information, please contact:
Head of Communications
D +44 (0)20 7264 8159
M +44 (0)7976 939864
Follow us on social media:
We are working with clients across our international network to help them minimise the impact of COVID-19 on their business and to prepare for what's next. To find out more, visit our dedicated Covid-19 hub.